June 15, 2024

By some estimates, greater than 500 firms promote automobile insurance coverage within the U.S. However regardless of the good breadth of the market, most automobile insurance coverage is offered by solely a handful of firms. In reality, the highest eight firms promote practically 73% of automobile insurance coverage, as measured by premium. 

When purchasing for insurance coverage, it is all the time a good suggestion to verify with some smaller firms. You could discover a lesser-known supplier that provides nice service at a low price. However chances are high you may additionally verify with some large manufacturers. Listed here are our evaluations of the eight largest automobile insurance coverage firms within the U.S. in 2023. 

Finest automobile insurance coverage firms in contrast 2023

Notice: Month-to-month premium knowledge is from latest research by USNews.com and WalletHub.

Our suggestions for the very best automobile insurance coverage firm for November 2023

Finest for affordable insurance coverage (non-military): Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual Auto Insurance coverage

JD Energy Buyer Satisfaction

870 (11)


  • Most cost-effective automobile insurance coverage in our evaluation.
  • Wide selection of reductions, together with UBI.
  • Buy on-line or from an agent.


  • Increased-than-average shopper complaints, based on NAIC.

Exterior of USAA, which is obtainable solely to pick out shoppers, Liberty Mutual affords the most affordable automobile insurance coverage in our evaluation. The corporate affords quite a lot of reductions to assist decrease the associated fee much more, together with these for having a violation-free document, having a number of Liberty Mutual insurance policies, being a home-owner, being a member of the U.S. army, being a superb pupil, and shopping for a coverage on-line.  

Liberty Mutual additionally affords RightTrack, a UBI program that advertises financial savings of as much as 30%.  

The corporate ranked eleventh in J.D. Energy’s buyer satisfaction survey. It has a higher-than-average variety of complaints, based on the NAIC.

Finest for youthful drivers: State Farm

State Farm Automotive Insurance coverage

JD Energy Buyer Satisfaction

882 (7)


  • Wide selection of reductions.
  • Extremely ranked by J.D. Energy.
  • A.M. Finest A++ score is an assurance of monetary power.


  • Offered solely by in-person brokers.

State Farm is the biggest auto insurance coverage firm and one of the recognizable manufacturers within the U.S. The corporate affords a variety of automobile insurance coverage reductions, together with these for having a number of insurance policies, being accident-free, defensive driving, and having sure car security options. It additionally affords a usage-based insurance coverage program known as Drive Protected and Save, which teases a possible 30% low cost for secure driving practices. 

Additionally of observe is the corporate’s Steer Clear program. An app-based program designed for these underneath the age of 25, Steer Clear helps these newer drivers develop secure driving habits whereas providing further reductions. 

Finest for on-line procuring expertise: Progressive

Progressive Automotive Insurance coverage

JD Energy Buyer Satisfaction

861 (16)


  • Offered each on-line and thru greater than 35,000 unbiased insurance coverage brokers.
  • Tied for first in J.D. Energy’s buyer satisfaction rankings for UBI packages.


  • Low rating in J.D. Energy’s total buyer satisfaction survey.
  • One of many dearer firms in our evaluation.

Again within the Nineteen Nineties, Progressive was one of many first insurance coverage firms to supply on-line coverage quotes and gross sales. In the present day, the corporate continues providing instruments to make shopping for on-line simple. These instruments embody Title Your Value, which helps you to see the very best mixture of coverages primarily based in your funds.

Progressive was additionally a pioneer in usage-based insurance coverage (UBI). Its Snapshot program affords reductions averaging $94 whenever you enroll and $231 on the finish of the six-month monitoring interval. It’s the one UBI program we all know of that ends after solely six months. So when you earn your low cost, the corporate not screens your driving habits.

Finest for reductions: GEICO

GEICO Automotive Insurance coverage

JD Energy Buyer Satisfaction

874 (9)


  • Wide selection of reductions, together with for affiliations.
  • Fewer-than-average buyer complaints.


  • Doesn’t promote potential financial savings for its UBI program.

GEICO affords a variety of reductions. These embody industry-standard choices reminiscent of these for being a superb driver, a superb pupil, having a number of GEICO insurance policies, insuring a number of automobiles, and having sure car security options. It additionally affords reductions for army members and quite a few skilled and tutorial affiliations.

The corporate ranked ninth—proper across the center—of J.D. Energy’s buyer satisfaction survey, and its C- grade from Crash Community is decrease than among the different firms in our evaluation. Nevertheless, based on the Nationwide Affiliation of Insurance coverage Commissioners (NAIC), GEICO acquired fewer than the typical variety of buyer complaints. 

Finest for low-mileage drivers: Allstate

AllState Automotive Insurance coverage

JD Energy Buyer Satisfaction

889 (5)


  • A number of financial savings choices for low mileage drivers.
  • A.M. Finest A++ score is an assurance of monetary power.


  • Costliest supplier in our evaluation.
  • Pay-as-you-go program shouldn’t be but accessible in each state.

Allstate is the most costly insurer in our evaluation. However like different giant insurance coverage firms, it affords a variety of reductions that can assist you get monetary savings. It ranks fifth in J.D. Energy’s buyer satisfaction research and has fewer than the typical variety of complaints, based on the NAIC.

Allstate is our choose for low-mileage drivers. Its Drivewise UBI program helps prospects save in the event that they drive fewer miles than common. And those that actually restrict how a lot they drive (for instance, retirees, metropolis dwellers who depend on public transportation, or stay-at-home employees) can attempt the corporate’s Milewise program. This can be a true “pay as you go” insurance coverage program, wherein you pay a day by day flat payment and a per-mile fee. 

Finest for U.S. army and their households: USAA

USAA Automotive Insurance coverage

JD Energy Buyer Satisfaction

890 (N/A)


  • Most cost-effective automobile insurance coverage in our survey.
  • A.M. Finest A++ score is an assurance of monetary power.


  • Obtainable solely to members of the U.S. army and their households.
  • Offered solely over the telephone; no on-line or agent gross sales.

USAA insurance coverage is solely for members of the U.S. army and their households. The corporate affords many reductions and options which might be just like these provided by different insurers. A number of of its reductions present assist and financial savings to these serving our nation. These embody reductions for storing a automobile on a army base, having a automobile in storage (for instance, when deployed abroad), and being a USAA legacy member.

The corporate is often known as a customer support chief. Its rating of 890 in J.D. Energy’s 2022 U.S. Auto Insurance coverage Buyer Satisfaction Examine would have positioned it on the high of the rankings (J.D. Energy scores USAA however doesn’t formally rank the corporate because of its unique buyer base).

Finest for newer vehicles: Farmers

Farmers Automotive Insurance coverage

JD Energy Buyer Satisfaction

882 (6)


  • Provides rideshare protection.
  • Provides UBI program known as Sign.


  • Second-most costly firm in our survey.
  • Increased-than-average shopper complaints, based on NAIC.

Farmers ranks within the high half of J.D. Energy’s 2022 U.S. Auto Insurance coverage Buyer Satisfaction Survey. Nevertheless, the corporate is the second-most costly in our evaluation and solely publishes a handful of obtainable reductions. These embody reductions for having a number of Farmers insurance policies and being a secure driver. The corporate affords a UBI program known as Sign. 

Farmers additionally affords new automobile alternative protection. In case your automobile is said a complete loss because of injury or theft, Farmers pays to switch it with a model new automobile of the identical make and mannequin. This non-obligatory characteristic applies to vehicles which might be not more than two mannequin years outdated and have fewer than 24,000 miles on them. 

If, then again, your new automobile is repairable, you may relaxation assured realizing Farmers pays for OEM elements once they’re accessible. 

Finest for hybrid/EV drivers: Vacationers

Vacationers Automotive Insurance coverage

JD Energy Buyer Satisfaction

854 (17)


  • Low-cost insurance coverage for EVs and hybrids.
  • A.M. Finest A++ score is an assurance of monetary power.


  • Lowest-ranked firm in J.D. Energy’s buyer satisfaction survey.
  • Intellidrive UBI program solely accessible in choose states.

Vacationers is the eighth-largest automobile insurance coverage firm within the U.S. However it might be on the leading edge on the subject of insuring electrical automobiles (EVs) and hybrids. In accordance with a latest research, Vacationers price 36% lower than common when in comparison with different firms’ prices for insuring an EV. It’s additionally the one firm we’ve discovered that provides a reduction particularly for EVs and hybrids. 

In fact, whether or not or not you drive an EV or hybrid, you’ll discover a variety of reductions from Vacationers. These embody these for having a number of Vacationers insurance policies, insuring a number of vehicles on the identical coverage, having steady insurance coverage with out a lapse, paying in full, and getting a quote properly upfront of the coverage begin date. 


We reviewed the highest eight U.S. automobile insurance coverage firms in 2022, based on knowledge revealed by the NAIC. Subsequent, we gathered respected third-party scores and rankings from a number of sources:

  • J.D. Energy is a shopper insights firm that gives annual rankings of U.S. insurance coverage firms. Our evaluation incorporates their most up-to-date rankings of automobile insurance coverage total buyer satisfaction and usage-based insurance coverage (UBI) packages. J.D. Energy charges firms on a 1,000-point scale then ranks these firms so as of their score. 
  •  Crashnetwork.com is a publication for the auto restore {industry}. Its collision restore grades are primarily based on a 2022 survey of store homeowners. Respondents had been requested to fee how properly every insurance coverage firm’s claims practices guarantee high quality repairs.
  • The NAIC gathers knowledge about shopper complaints to their state insurance coverage division referencing particular insurers. An index beneath 1.0 means the corporate has fewer complaints than common. An index above 1.0 means extra complaints than common.
  • A.M. Finest is an unbiased, trusted supplier of analytics and scores specializing within the international insurance coverage {industry}. Its scores point out an insurance coverage firm’s monetary power and skill to pay claims. 

We additionally reviewed every firm’s web site to know reductions provided, availability of UBI and different packages, and different options. Subsequent, we developed a number of “better of” classes, inserting firms the place we judged applicable. 

Learn how to choose the very best automobile insurance coverage firm

It may be robust to find out what makes one automobile insurance coverage firm higher than one other. Including to the problem is that high U.S. automobile insurers spend billions of {dollars} collectively on promoting. It looks as if you may hardly flip round typically with out seeing one other automobile insurance coverage advert on a display or billboard.

Attempt to take an goal strategy to make sure you get the very best automobile insurance coverage firm to your wants. Listed here are some ideas. 

Have a look at third-party evaluations and rankings

J.D. Energy has ranked the nation’s high automobile insurers primarily based on customer support and claims satisfaction for years. Summaries of those research are simple to search out with an internet search. Different third-party insurance coverage firm evaluations and rankings come from organizations reminiscent of A.M. Finest, Demotech, Crash Community, and NAIC. 

Ask for suggestions

Discuss to folks you belief—household, buddies, co-workers, neighbors—to see if there are any firms they’d (or wouldn’t) advocate. 

Get quotes from a number of automobile insurance coverage firms

Insurance coverage prices differ between firms, typically by lots of of {dollars} per yr. Be sure you get quotes from at the very least three or 4 firms to make sure you get the most affordable premium for the protection you want.

Discuss to an unbiased insurance coverage agent

Impartial insurance coverage brokers are licensed professionals who can get you the coverage you want at a value that fits your funds. These brokers usually symbolize a number of firms (together with smaller firms which will price lower than the massive insurers), to allow them to deal with the procuring legwork in your behalf. 

You may have many decisions for automobile insurance coverage. However nearly three-quarters of protection within the U.S. is offered by only a handful of enormous firms. Use unbiased, third-party scores and our cautious evaluations to know exactly what these firms supply. 

Incessantly requested questions (FAQs)

What are the various kinds of automobile insurance coverage?

A automobile insurance coverage coverage consists of a number of coverages. Most states require legal responsibility protection, which pays for different drivers’ accidents or car injury if you happen to’re decided to be at fault in an accident. Some states require private damage safety (PIP), which pays medical payments no matter which driver is at fault. Complete and collision coverages, which assist pay for injury to your personal automobile in particular circumstances, are often required by a lender if you happen to finance your automobile. 

Which components have an effect on your automobile insurance coverage premium?

The price of automobile insurance coverage is affected by a variety of things. These embody your age, gender, driving document, dwelling ZIP code and the yr, make, and mannequin of your automobile. Premiums additionally differ by insurance coverage firm, as every insurer should value their coverage based on the distinctive wants of their enterprise.  

What are automobile insurance coverage {industry} developments?

The price of automobile insurance coverage has been on the rise in recent times. In accordance with a latest research by Insurify, premiums rose 17% nationally within the first half of 2023. This improve was pushed by inflated prices of auto elements and restore labor.

All of this underscores the must be a wise insurance coverage shopper. Store your insurance coverage yearly, ask about insurance coverage reductions, and—particularly if you happen to’re a secure driver—contemplate enrolling in a usage-based insurance coverage (UBI) program.

What’s usage-based insurance coverage?

Utilization-based insurance coverage (UBI) makes use of telematics expertise to trace specific features of your driving. This info is transmitted routinely to your insurance coverage firm and used to calculate potential reductions. Sometimes, info is gathered both by a smartphone app or a tool you plug in underneath your automobile’s sprint. Behaviors reminiscent of driving much less, avoiding driving at night time, and driving on the posted velocity restrict may help you earn reductions.

How lengthy do it’s important to report an accident to your insurance coverage firm?

Deadlines for submitting a declare differ by insurance coverage firm. Some enable as much as two or three years. Examine your coverage contract or contact your insurance coverage agent to know your declare deadlines.

Whatever the time allowed, submitting a declare as quickly as potential is all the time a good suggestion.  

How does an insurance coverage firm worth a automobile?

Insurance coverage firms usually worth vehicles primarily based on precise money worth (ACV). ACV is a depreciated worth primarily based on what the corporate determines somebody would pay for the automobile on the open market.