December 10, 2023

Vacationers Insurance coverage has a variety of protection choices to help you customise a coverage to your particular wants, plus comparatively low charges. However how does Vacationers evaluate to different automotive insurers—and must you put it in your shortlist? 

TIME’s Take

In contrast with the nationwide common, Vacationers’s charges are barely decrease, particularly you probably have poor credit score or a driving violation. What’s extra, the corporate has a “Superior” ranking from AM Greatest, which speaks to its monetary power. However low scores from J.D. Energy for declare satisfaction and insurance coverage purchasing could also be off-putting to some. 

Execs and cons

Decrease-than-average annual charges

Decrease-than-average J.D. Energy scores for declare satisfaction and insurance coverage purchasing

Wide selection of protection choices and reductions

Rideshare insurance coverage not supplied in most states

Two accident forgiveness plans out there

Decrease-than-average buyer complaints

Vacationers’s automotive insurance coverage charges usually are not the very best of its rivals, however they’re additionally not the bottom. When in comparison with the nationwide common, Vacationers’s common annual price is 12% much less.

Vacationers’s charges are barely increased total than rivals State Farm and Geico, however a lot decrease than Allstate’s charges. What’s extra, drivers who’ve been in an accident or convicted of a DUI might discover Vacationers’s pricing extra forgiving than that of different insurance coverage firms. As with all insurers, the precise price you’ll pay will rely on a number of various factors.

The desk beneath lists the common annual charges for Vacationers, Allstate, State Farm, and Geico based mostly on the kind of protection chosen, the shopper’s credit score rating and age, and the existence of any site visitors violations on the driving force’s file.

By protection

By credit score rating

By age group

By violation

Supply: Knowledge from Quadrant by way of USA In the present day

How a lot is Vacationers automotive insurance coverage?

The precise value of Vacationers automotive insurance coverage will rely on a number of components. These components embrace the kind of protection chosen, the driving force’s age and credit score rating, and any historical past of site visitors violations. 

Protection kind

Each state requires drivers to hold a minimal quantity of legal responsibility insurance coverage to have the ability to drive legally. Minimal necessities range amongst states, so it’s smart to test along with your native division of motor automobiles to find out the sort and quantity of protection you’ll want. Vacationers clients pay a median of $1,273 per yr for minimal protection and a median of $1,437 per yr for full protection, which might embrace complete, collision, uninsured or underinsured motorist, and bodily damage protection.

Credit score rating

Your credit score rating impacts a lot of your monetary life, and insurance coverage is not any exception. Basically, you possibly can count on to pay a decrease premium in case your credit score rating falls within the “good” or “glorious” vary, and the next premium for a “poor” or “truthful” credit score rating. Vacationers has a median annual price of $2,361 for purchasers with poor and truthful credit score scores.

Age group

Automobile insurance coverage premiums are typically the very best for younger drivers, with charges typically reducing once you attain the 25-to-30 age vary. Vacationers’s charges mirror this sample, with teen drivers paying a median of $4,704 and grownup drivers paying a median of $1,392. 

Visitors violation

In case your driving file is clear, you’ll take pleasure in decrease insurance coverage premiums. However you probably have a dashing ticket, accident, or DUI in your file, you possibly can count on to pay extra for automotive insurance coverage. Vacationers has a median annual price of $1,355 for drivers with clear information, $1,785 for drivers with one dashing ticket on their file, $1,890 for drivers who’ve been concerned in an accident, and $2,143 for drivers with one DUI.

Vacationers auto insurance coverage reductions

Like most insurance coverage suppliers, Vacationers presents a number of reductions to assist lower the price of protection for purchasers. The commonest reductions are as follows:

Multi-policy low cost

Bundling is a typical method to decrease your insurance coverage premiums. Vacationers presents a multi-policy low cost which might help you save as much as 13% in your automotive insurance coverage premiums by bundling your auto coverage with householders or rental insurance coverage. You may additionally be capable of bundle different kinds of protection to take pleasure in a multi-policy low cost.

Multi-car low cost

In the event you personal a couple of automotive, you might be eligible for a reduction with Vacationers insurance coverage. The multi-car low cost is accessible for households that insure two or extra automobiles below the identical coverage.

Homeownership low cost

Whereas bundling is one of the simplest ways to get a reduction, Vacationers additionally presents a homeownership low cost to those that insure their properties or condos with one other insurer—although the low cost isn’t more likely to be as intensive as it could be when bundling dwelling and automotive insurance coverage below the identical supplier.

Protected driver low cost

In the event you drive safely and preserve a clear driving file, you might be eligible for the Vacationers secure driver low cost. To qualify, you could haven’t any accidents, no violations, and no main complete claims in your coverage for 3 to 5 years. 

Steady insurance coverage low cost

Vacationers rewards long-time clients with the continual insurance coverage low cost. In the event you’ve held automotive insurance coverage insurance policies with Vacationers repeatedly, with no gaps in protection, you might be able to get this low cost to decrease your premiums.

Hybrid or electrical automotive low cost

Leasing or buying an eco-friendly automotive might get you a further low cost. Vacationers presents a hybrid/electrical automotive low cost for purchasers who decide to being environmentally pleasant drivers by buying another gasoline automobile.

New automotive low cost

Vacationers’ new automotive low cost is relevant for automobiles which can be lower than three years outdated. This low cost applies to present clients who buy a brand new automotive or new clients whose current automobile is lower than three years outdated.

EFT, pay in full, and good payer reductions

There are a number of methods to save lots of on automotive insurance coverage by the way you select to pay your premiums. First, you might be supplied a reduction by paying your annual Vacationers auto premium in full moderately than in month-to-month installments. You can even qualify for a reduction when you pay with digital funds switch (EFT) or when you persistently pay your premiums early or on time.

Early quote low cost

The early quote low cost applies to new Vacationers clients. In the event you get a automotive insurance coverage quote earlier than your coverage along with your current insurer expires, you could possibly be eligible for a reduction when you swap.

Good pupil low cost

In case you have a driver in your coverage who’s enrolled in highschool or school full time, they’ll get a reduction on their Vacationers insurance coverage premiums by sustaining no less than a B common.

Pupil-away-at-school low cost

When your youngster leaves for school, you would possibly need to preserve them as a named driver in your coverage for once they’re visiting dwelling, however they probably received’t be driving the automotive throughout time period time. On this case, you could possibly get a student-away-at-school low cost, which Vacationers has in place for purchasers with dependents who go to high school no less than 100 miles away from dwelling.

Driver coaching low cost

Younger drivers are at a a lot increased threat for getting in a automotive accident. Drivers who enroll in driver training programs to hone their driving abilities might be eligible for a driver coaching low cost with Vacationers.

Extra about Vacationers auto insurance coverage

Nonetheless undecided whether or not Vacationers Insurance coverage is the best alternative on your auto insurance coverage protection? Right here’s extra about Vacationers to see if it’s price contemplating or when you ought to go along with one other insurance coverage supplier on your auto coverage.

Who’s eligible for Vacationers automotive insurance coverage?

Any driver with a license is eligible to use for protection with Vacationers, however that doesn’t imply it’ll be your best option for all drivers or that each one drivers might be accredited for protection. 

As famous earlier, drivers who’ve a dashing ticket or DUI on their file might discover cheaper charges with Vacationers than with different insurance coverage suppliers. As well as, these with poor credit score scores might discover that they pay decrease premiums with Vacationers than with its rivals.


Vacationers Insurance coverage has a superb popularity within the insurance coverage trade. Not solely are its charges aggressive (and, in some instances, decrease than its rivals), Vacationers additionally has a good popularity on the subject of customer support.

One of the crucial necessary components to contemplate when looking for auto insurance coverage is whether or not or not your chosen supplier will be capable of pay out claims as promised. AM Greatest, a world credit score company that makes a speciality of the insurance coverage trade, opinions the monetary well being of insurance coverage firms and charges them based mostly on their monetary power, which interprets to their skill to pay claims. Vacationers Insurance coverage has an AM Greatest ranking of A++, or “Superior,” which speaks to the power of its robust working efficiency. This ranking can present clients with further peace of thoughts when selecting Vacationers for his or her insurance coverage wants.

Vacationers additionally has below-average buyer complaints to the Nationwide Affiliation of Insurance coverage Commissioners (NAIC)—63% fewer auto insurance coverage complaints, to be precise—which is reassuring to potential clients. Nonetheless, within the J.D. Energy 2022 U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Examine, Vacationers was rated beneath trade common at 854 out of 1,000 (the trade common being 873 out of 1,000), which might elevate crimson flags for some. Equally, Vacationers got here in final place within the J.D. Energy 2022 U.S. Insurance coverage Purchasing Examine with 853 out of 1,000 (in comparison with a section common of 863 out of 1,000).

On the finish of the day, if you’ll find a superb deal on auto insurance coverage with Vacationers, you would possibly be capable of overlook the crimson flags. Nevertheless it’s smart to collect further quotes from competing insurers earlier than making a call both means.

Different Vacationers Insurance coverage companies

Along with automotive insurance coverage, Vacationers presents the next insurance coverage merchandise:

  • Boat and yacht insurance coverage.
  • Apartment insurance coverage.
  • Flood insurance coverage.
  • Owners insurance coverage.
  • Landlord insurance coverage.
  • Bike insurance coverage.
  • Pet insurance coverage.
  • Renters insurance coverage.
  • Journey insurance coverage.
  • Umbrella insurance coverage.
  • Precious gadgets insurance coverage.
  • Wedding ceremony and occasion insurance coverage.

Vacationers additionally presents enterprise insurance coverage protection, together with basic legal responsibility, industrial auto and trucking, inland marine, property, staff compensation, and surety bonds.

Which states does Vacationers Insurance coverage cowl?

Vacationers Insurance coverage covers a large swath of the US, from California to Georgia and past. It presents protection in 42 states, plus Washington, D.C. In the event you dwell exterior Vacationers’s protection space, you’ll must look elsewhere for automotive insurance coverage protection. States the place protection is just not out there embrace Alaska, Hawaii, Louisiana, Michigan, North and South Dakota, West Virginia, and Wyoming.

Which different insurers must you contemplate?

Along with Vacationers and the rivals listed above (Allstate, State Farm, and Geico), it’s price contemplating Liberty Mutual on your automotive insurance coverage wants. Not solely does Liberty supply reductions for homeownership and good grades, it additionally offers a army low cost that may assist cut back insurance coverage prices for lively, retired, or reserve members of one of many U.S. Armed Forces branches. Liberty Mutual additionally has a program referred to as RightTrack, which tracks your driving habits and will earn you as much as 30% off your premiums.

Liberty Mutual Auto Insurance coverage

JD Energy Buyer Satisfaction

870 (11)


  • Extensive choice of protection choices and reductions
  • Higher pricing than rivals in a number of classes
  • Potential 30% low cost by taking part in its RightTrack UBI program
  • A.M. Greatest A ranking for monetary power


  • Some states don’t look like served by an agent
  • Middling claims and customer support rankings

Different choices embrace American Household, Nationwide, Farmers, Progressive, and USAA (for army members). It’s a good suggestion to request quotes from a number of suppliers earlier than selecting who to go along with as your automotive insurance coverage firm.

Backside line

In the event you’re on the lookout for a automotive insurance coverage supplier, Vacationers is effectively price contemplating. Though precise charges will rely in your age, driving historical past, and the quantity and sort of protection you need, you possibly can count on lower-than-average premiums. As well as, Vacationers has an extended checklist of insurance coverage reductions that may assist decrease your total prices. Ultimately, it’s price getting a quote from Vacationers to see if it’s a superb match.

Steadily requested questions (FAQs)

Is Vacationers good automotive insurance coverage?

General, Vacationers is an efficient choice to contemplate for automotive insurance coverage. Whereas the corporate’s rankings by J.D. Energy for declare satisfaction and insurance coverage purchasing are decrease than common, it does have a “Superior” ranking from AM Greatest and a lower-than-average variety of NAIC complaints. Charges are additionally decrease than common for a lot of clients, although they might not be the bottom clients will discover. It’s advisable to get quotes from no less than three insurance coverage suppliers to find out which one presents the perfect protection on the most reasonably priced value for you.

Is Vacationers Insurance coverage costly?

The price of a Vacationers Insurance coverage coverage depends upon a number of components: the kind of protection, age and driving historical past of the policyholder, and extra. Nonetheless, normally, Vacationers Insurance coverage premiums are decrease than common for auto insurance coverage.

How do I contact Vacationers?

There are a number of methods to contact Vacationers:

  • By cellphone at (800) 842-5075.
  • The MyTravelers app (out there on Google Play and the Apple App Retailer).
  • E mail utilizing an internet kind.

Does Vacationers supply rideshare insurance coverage?

Sure. Vacationers does supply rideshare insurance coverage—however solely in two states (Colorado and Illinois). One of these protection is accessible as an endorsement to an auto insurance coverage coverage.